Join jaguars.com senior editor Vic Ketchman as he tackles the fans' tough questions.
Chadwin from Oak Ridge, TN
Here's a hypothetical question on the draft. Say you have the first pick of the draft and you have the next coming of Peyton Manning as the top player in the draft (or John Elway or Joe Montana, what have you), but you already have an established QB at the helm (say a David Garrard or Carson Palmer). Do you follow the BAP approach or do you follow the PSS approach, even though the best players in the draft at other positions are way below this top-rated QB?
Vic: You take the PSS approach, of course. Why would you draft the next Peyton Manning, John Elway or Joe Montana when you already have a David Garrard or Carson Palmer? Maybe you have a need at wide receiver and you could get a Ted Ginn or a Dwayne Bowe. You gotta take one of those guys so you can go to the Super Bowl next season.
Tim from Paris, TN
Is it possible for some of the top talent coming out of college (Chris Long, Darren McFadden, etc.) to skip the draft and enter as a free agent, to have all 32 teams have a bidding war with the highest contract landing the player?
Vic: No, it is not possible. No player can enter the NFL without a year of having been eligible to be drafted.
Trevor from Washington, DC
I am now convinced you do not read my emails.
Vic: You’re right, I don’t.
Mark from Jacksonville
“NFL Network” ranked the Jaguars as fifth-best team in the NFL. What is your opinion?
Vic: I have them sixth right now, but that could change, depending on whether or not the Jaguars are able to trade up to draft a defensive end.
Johnny from Jacksonville
What will be the first day the fans can come out and watch the Jags practice?
Vic: Mini-camp will be open to the public. The dates for mini-camp aren’t ready to be announced, yet, but mini-camp will occur later in the spring this year than it has in past years.
John from Neptune Beach, FL
Meaningless trivia, but it ties to your Pittsburgh theme: The only two days of the year when a professional game is not regularly scheduled are the days immediately before and after the major league all-star game. Could Jacksonville ever support a schedule like that?
Vic: Thank you for that startling piece of information, John. It takes years and years to develop the habit of attending sporting events to be able to support that kind of schedule.
Tommie from Jacksonville
Since stats from different eras should not be the only measurement for greatness, then please explain to me why Bob Hayes has not been inducted into the Hall of Fame? Is there any truth to the rumor that he changed the way teams employed their secondaries to cover him?
Vic: It’s not a rumor, it’s a fact that Bob Hayes changed the game. His speed changed the way defenses played. Hayes made football a speed game and, in my opinion, he would be in the Hall of Fame today if he hadn’t made one terrible mistake: In the biggest game of his life, the “Ice Bowl,” he stuck his hands in his pants and didn’t come off the line of scrimmage on running plays. That embittered the old-guard writers on the Hall of Fame selection committee. Hayes’ “Ice Bowl” performance, combined with his off-the-field problems and his lack of a defining postseason game or moment conspired to keep him out of the Hall of Fame.
David from New Orleans, LA
I appreciate that you mentioned not to view stats as the end all, be all to determine greatness. That being said, I have only seen Johnny Unitas play in NFL Films documentaries. To you, what made him so great that someone should know that they can't read from his stats sheet?
Vic: First of all, he was the star of the most important game ever played, the 1958 NFL title game, but if you’re looking for a great stat, try this: Unitas threw at least one touchdown pass in 47 consecutive games. No one has even come close to tying that record. Beyond all of that, Unitas was a great leader. He was in complete control of the huddle and anyone watching the game in the stands or on television knew it. It was his offense and his huddle and no one dared speak in it but him. His coach, Don Shula, once sent a play into the game with a messenger player. Unitas called time out, went to the sideline and told Shula to get that player out of the game because they weren’t gonna run that play. You didn’t need to look at the stats to know what made Unitas great. All you had to do was watch the game. He invented the two-minute drill. Everything the game is today is because of Johnny Unitas. He gave every breath of his life to the game and he died crippled by it. Every crew cut belongs to him. Every pair of high-top black shoes were his. Growing up, Joe Namath intentionally made himself stoop-shouldered so he could look more like Unitas. What Unitas didn’t earn in the way of financial reward from playing football, he achieved in fame. He is the father of the modern era of professional football.
Gamble from San Francisco, CA
I always loved the steal the Jags pulled over Buffalo. Rob Johnson for the ninth pick, which we got to use on one of the best players in Jags history. Oh, my, that was a sweet trade.
Vic: And every yard Fred gains makes it even better.
Asley from Jacksonville
Well, Vic, while you may beat around the bush with your own fans about Jason Taylor, because for some reason you don't feel like giving us the info we want, there's a columnist with the “Miami Herald” who did. He said the Jags are really considering Taylor but that it will come down to agreeing on picks. That’s what we want to hear, inside info; great move or bad call. Now what do you think?
Vic: So he’s saying the Jaguars might trade for Taylor if they can agree with the Dolphins on what picks are to be given to the Dolphins in exchange. Wow! That’s a great story. That’s what I call inside information.
Frank from Jacksonville
When is D.D. Terry going to join the two-headed monster? I think he’s very talented.
Vic: I don’t know about joining the two-headed monster because then it would have to have three heads, but I can tell you the Jaguars are very high on Terry. He made great progress on the practice squad last season and they think he can be an outstanding special teams player for them this year and they also believe that down the road he can develop into a top third-down back. He’s a player we should watch closely this spring. I expect him to make a move.
Ken from Jacksonville
I agree about stats. Eyes don’t lie. You watch old footage of Jim Brown and others and what you see is undeniable. Two of my favorites to watch old footage on are Hugh McElhenny, who did everything Barry Sanders could do, and Tommy McDonald. I don’t have any idea what their stats were but my eyes tell me they were as good as anyone.
Vic: I wouldn’t compare McElhenny to Sanders. McElhenny, known as “The King,” was a big back. At 6-1, 200, there weren’t many defensive backs in his day who could tackle him. McElhenny was at the end of his career when I was a kid and old enough to watch football, but I can still remember some of his wild romps through the secondary. He could do it all; run with power, speed, elusiveness and catch the ball, too. He was a five-time All-Pro and was inducted into the Hall of Fame in 1970. As I look back on him, I see some Fred in him. He had that wild power and cutback ability Fred has. Tommy McDonald was the last of the no-facemask guys. He was a little guy (5-9, 178) with fantastic hands, short-area speed and quickness and the courage to go over the middle face-first against linebackers who dreamed about ripping his nose off. I don’t think I ever watched McDonald play that he didn’t have a bloody nose. I remember once watching a game in which McDonald and Bobby Layne were playing against each other – neither one wore a facemask – and they each had a bloody nose. The first time I saw Wes Welker play, I thought to myself, “That’s Tommy McDonald.” McDonald was a four-time All-Pro and was inducted into the Hall of Fame in 1998. McElhenny and McDonald would’ve been stars in today’s game, too.
Bill from Jacksonville Beach, FL
I heard you on the radio last night and you described this draft class as maybe the worst since 1985. Wouldn't it make sense then that if you're going to try to trade up to get one of the top players, this would be the year to do it?
Vic: That’s a popular train of thought this year. A lot of teams want to either trade up or trade picks for a veteran player, such as Jason Taylor.