Hornung, Taylor were the best

Tuesday, March 25, 2008 | Ask Vic






Join jaguars.com senior editor Vic Ketchman as he tackles the fans' tough questions.



John from Jacksonville
In an uncapped system, how would the process of signing drafted players change? Would they continue to fall in line based on draft position? Or would you have small-market teams trying to pay a first overall pick less than the second overall pick that a large market team is trying to sign?
Vic: It’s been so long since we’ve had an uncapped system that it’s impossible to answer your question. The first few years in an uncapped system might be a Wild West show, but it would eventually settle down. In an uncapped system, the small-market teams would be expected to pay less than the large-market teams. It was that way prior to the advent of the salary cap system. In other words, if you were a high draft prospect in an uncapped system, you’d rather be selected by a large-market/high-revenue team than by a small-market/low-revenue team.
Kenan from Jacksonville
Who do you think is our biggest rival, the Titans, Colts or Steelers?
Vic: Titans.
Robin from Orlando, FL
What is position-specific selection?
Vic: It’s a fancy way of saying “drafting for need,” without admitting that you have needs.
Jonathan from Olympia, WA
I just read a report that Quinn Gray is ready to sign a deal for $645,000 for one year with Houston to be the third quarterback. The Jaguars paid Lemon a lot more than that over a lot more years. What was wrong with Gray? Why spend the money on Lemon when we probably could have re-signed Gray for less money?
Vic: Gray wanted to find a team that would give him an opportunity to compete for a starting job and would commit to that opportunity contractually. The Jaguars were not that team and apparently Gray couldn’t find a team that would make that commitment. The Jaguars couldn’t wait for Gray to find that out. I think that should be easily understood.
Harold from Greenville, NC
Regarding the question of who you think was the best RB combo of all time, what about Jim Kiick and Larry Csonka of the Dolphins?
Vic: Csonka and Kiick were outstanding. So were Franco Harris and Rocky Bleier, another running back tandem from the same period of time. There are several great running back tandems: Kevin Mack and Earnest Byner of the Browns, Warrick Dunn and Mike Alstott of the Bucs, Jim Brown and Ernie Green of the Browns, etc. First of all, you have to have a system that allows for two guys who are runners, as opposed to the contemporary running back/blocking back system. I offered Dave Osborn and Bill Brown on Monday for no real reason other than I thought they were an especially complementary pair of running backs. Here’s another great pair: Cookie Gilchrist and Billy Joe. If you really want to know who the best of all-time are, the answer is very easy: It’s Paul Hornung and Jim Taylor. They were the best inside-out combination I’ve ever seen and they’re both in the Hall of Fame.
Mike from Aberystwyth, Wales
Where do you see Gerald Sensabaugh fitting in next year?
Vic: I got a new appreciation for Sensabaugh on Monday. I wasn’t aware that he had played with a torn labrum in one shoulder before he blew out the other one in week two of last season. The guy played a whole season with a bad shoulder. Do you know how tough it is to tackle a running back or tight end in the open field with a shoulder that moves out of place and leaves you writhing in pain? Sensabaugh had developed a little bit of a reputation as a guy who would miss tackles in the open field and now I know why. With two good shoulders now, he might be a new man.
Greg from Jacksonville
In your story about the beginning of offseason conditioning you stated that Mike Walker will not be completely ready to go until training camp. I'm guessing the Jaguars, or any other team, would not have drafted Mike Walker on the first day of the draft if they would have known his knee would not have been ready for the ’07 season. Is there a strong sense of worry that Walker may not pan out medically, or is it not a big deal in a recovery from his type of injury?
Vic: I think there has to be concern for his knee. Walker is a sensational talent and it would be a terrible shame if a knee injury limited the degree to which he can express his talent. Last spring and early in training camp, before the repetitions caught up with him, Walker looked like a young Jimmy Smith. Then, all of a sudden, he disappeared. Part of the problem was that he was playing with a significant hand injury that made it painful for him to catch the football, but the play I remember the most was a go route up the sideline in a preseason game. The ball was thrown for Walker to go up above a smaller defender and make the catch, but he didn’t have enough strength in his knee to jump. That’s when it became obvious his knee needed more attention. In selecting Walker, the Jaguars saw six or seven players they had rated go off the board in order just ahead of their pick. It’s one of those rare situations where a team sees its board evaporate right before its eyes. Minnesota tight end Matt Spaeth was one of the prospects and the Jaguars had to figure the Steelers wouldn’t take Spaeth because the Steelers have Heath Miller, but take Spaeth they did. The Jaguars knew Walker had the knee issue, but after that run on their board, Walker’s speed and pass-catching ability were too good to pass up.
Blake from Coral Springs, FL
In your article Porter leads Jags in smiles you said “Sensabaugh is being counted on to compete for the starting strong safety position.” If that's the case, why is he still a restricted free agent and hasn't been signed yet? I'm just a bit confused.
Vic: Sensabaugh hasn’t signed the tender and that’s because the RFA signing period doesn’t end for another month. Even though the Jaguars tendered him at the second-round level, he could still be signed to an offer sheet by another team. If that doesn’t happen, and it’s not likely it will, Sensabaugh will almost certainly sign the tender when the RFA signing period ends. Signing it now would take him off the market.
Adrian from Inglewood, CA
Because of you, I've become a smarter fan. I don't walk around like the average ignorant fan that believes their team is the best and never loses. “Ask Vic” is like my bible.
Vic: I say unto you, just win, baby, win.
Bill from Panama City, Panama
Many in the national media paint Jerry Porter as a problem; a malcontent with an attitude. I could not see it on his interview. Have you talked with him and, if so, how does he impress you?
Vic: I’ve interviewed him on the phone and I’ve interviewed him in person and all indications are that he’s intent on winning the “Byron Leftwich Memorial Best Interview on the Team” award.
Chris from St. Augustine, FL
I was just wondering if you were ever going to put up a new fan poll question?
Vic: Maybe it’s time to do another “Is Vic an idiot?” poll.
Darren from Victoria, BC
Chad Johnson refers to himself as “Ocho Cinco,” which, in Spanish translation, is eight five. If he wanted to be called his number (85), it would really be Ochente Cinco.
Vic: Why Spanish? Why not, say, Polish?
Chris from Hudson, FL
I was wondering if you knew exactly what day the NFL was going to release their 2008 schedule with the times and dates?
Vic: The schedule is usually released after the March league meetings and this year’s meetings are next week. Be on the lookout the following week.
Damien from Jacksonville
Do you think the Jags should trade for Chad Johnson?
Vic: Sure, you can never have enough wide receivers.
Mark from Dubai, UAE
Great column on Monday; put together like a comic act. Tiger Woods is building his first golf course here in Dubai. Once completed, would you come try it out?
Vic: Are you one of those flowing robes guys? Can you arrange to have a private jet pick me up, fly me to the course and give me total consciousness when I die? If you can, get me a tee time.
Mike from Savannah, GA
The 40-yard dash is overrated. It's mixing top speed and acceleration without indicating which is the major contributor. And the bench press looks silly when linebackers put up more reps than offensive linemen. It almost seems like a waste of time to put those guys through these tests. Are the results really that valued by organizations?
Vic: Yes, they are. Teams know how to use that information. There’s a 10-yard split in the 40 time that tells a team how quick a player is. The bench press says something about the player’s conditioning and work ethic. You don’t draft guys because of what they do at the combine, but the combine provides more information on the players you’re considering and more information is always better than less information.
James from Jacksonville
What do you think of Roger Goodell's decision to punish the 49ers for tampering, with proof that wouldn't even hold water in a court of law? It seems like he should punish every team that signed a player on the first day of free agency. What is he doing?
Vic: Maybe he’s attempting to send a message to every team through one team.





Have a question for Vic?

Your Name:

Your Hometown (City, State):
 

Your Email Address:
 

Questions without a Firstname and Hometown will not be considered. Your email address will only be used to contact you for the purposes of clarification or customer service contact. We will not use the email address collected here for other purposes.

Your Question:
 

 





  Privacy Policy | Public Relations | Radio Partners

Copyright © 2008 Jacksonville Jaguars and the NFL. All Rights Reserved.
Do not duplicate content in any form without permission of the Jacksonville Jaguars.
Powered on Peak 10 WTEV TV-47 Jacksonville
NFL.com NFL Kids Under the Helmet NFL Shop NFL High School NFL Europe Hall of Fame Super Bowl NFLPlayers.com NFL Alumni Join the Team NFL Network NFLatino
Bengals Bills Broncos Browns Chargers Chiefs Colts Dolphins Jaguars Jets Patriots Raiders Ravens Steelers Texans Titans
49ers Bears Buccaneers Cardinals Cowboys Eagles Falcons Giants Lions Packers Panthers Rams Redskins Saints Seahawks Vikings